September 3, 1945
|Brady Residence Hellstern Residence|
The investigation of the double-murder at Lunt and Clark was immediately underway. Based on the dying description of his victim, the murderer was 30 or 35 years old, about 5 feet 10 inches in height, with a dirty complexion, a slouch hat, blue shirt, and dark trousers. He wore a single black rubber glove on his left hand, suggesting that he may have had an artificial or injured hand.
Three people claimed to have seen the killer. Elmer Leitner, 22, of 1772 W. Estes, Paul Piro, 18, of 1908 W. Estes, and Opal Hamann, of 6959 N. Clark. They corroborated Detective Brady's description, but didn't add much new information.
|Mrs. Brady Mrs. Hellstern|
As the police investigated, the families grieved. At that time, widows of police killed in the line of duty received $10,000, along with $1,800 per year until their youngest child reached the age of 18. Converted into today's values that would translate to a lump sum of $132,000 and $24,000 per year. Of course, no amount of money could replace the loss of a husband or father.
|Location of Inquest|
The inquest pointed to a potential motive. At the time of his death, Detective Hellstern had over $3,000 in cash in his pocket. His fellow officers noted that he distrusted banks. Could his murder have been a hold-up that went bad? Did the man with the black rubber glove know that Detective Hellstern would be carrying a large sum of money that night? What was he planning to buy? It wasn't clear, and his wife never gave an explanation of why he was carrying the modern day equivalent of $39,000 as he was walking down Clark Street.
|Boundaries of the Search|
In an effort to gather additional evidence, the police began a systematic interview of every individual in the Rogers Park community. Officers swarmed through the streets, the local Rogers Park force augmented by squads from the detective bureau, the homicide bureau, and even the park district. All told there were 127 uniformed policeman and 10 plainclothes detectives working on this case. These officers were sent on a house-by-house investigation throughout the neighborhood, interviewing local community members about the crime. Their search turned up Mel Ogren, who had been bowling that night at the corner of Lunt and Ravenswood, and witnessed the exchange of gunfire on his walk home. He was positive there had been no glove, contradicting several eye witness accounts.
|Sherwood Wolf, 19|
A few days later, Sherwood J. Wolf, 19, of 7006 N. Paulina was arrested. Mr. Wolf was supposedly the Peeping Tom that the detectives had been on their way to investigate. Maybe he was a little creepy, but the police quickly discovered that he had nothing to do with the murders. It was a dead end. To share the killer's description more widely, the police generated a sketch based upon the statements given by witnesses. Since forensic artists were still rather uncommon, the portrait was drawn by an artist friend of Captain Ahern. It
was displayed at the Rogers Park police station.
Eight additional witnesses identified in the canvassing of the neighborhood were interviewed by police. Paul McMahon of 1648 W. Lunt confirmed that the shooter had a glove on his left hand.
By the end of September, the police had little to show for their community-wide manhunt. After hundreds of interviews, the arrest of Sherwood Wolf, and some new eye witness testimony, all they had was an amateur sketch of the perpetrator, a half-baked theory about a robbery, and a fruitless search for a man with a glove on his left hand. But the case would come roaring back into the headlines on December 14th when the events of that evening would finally be revealed, along with the identity of the murderer.
Part 3 to follow.
Information above is taken from a series of Chicago Tribune articles accessed through the Chicago Public Library.